Rebranding After a Trademark Conflict in Arizona: Is a New DBA Enough?

Receiving a trademark cease-and-desist letter can be unsettling for any business owner. You may have spent months—or years—building a business around a name, developing a website, printing packaging, creating social media accounts, and building recognition with customers.

Then another company claims that your name infringes its trademark rights.

Sometimes the appropriate response is to fight. Sometimes there is room to negotiate. And sometimes, after evaluating the strength of the competing claims and the cost of continuing the dispute, the most practical business decision is to rebrand.

That leads to an important question for Arizona business owners:

If I need to stop using my current business name, do I actually have to change the legal name of my LLC? Or can I register a new trade name or DBA and simply operate under the new brand?

The answer is: sometimes a trade name is enough—but trademark law and business-name registration are two very different things.

Understanding that distinction can prevent a business owner from solving one trademark problem only to create another.

Your LLC Name Is Not Necessarily Your Trademark

One of the biggest misconceptions about trademarks is that registering an LLC gives you trademark rights in the LLC's name.

It does not.

An Arizona limited liability company is formed through the Arizona Corporation Commission. The ACC reviews business names to determine whether they satisfy Arizona's entity-name requirements. But the ACC expressly warns that its determination is only ministerial and that registering an entity name does not grant trademark rights or resolve competing claims to the name. In fact, the ACC warns that a business can receive approval for an entity name and still infringe another party's trademark.

Trademark law asks a different question.

A trademark identifies the source of goods or services. When customers see a particular name, logo, slogan, or other brand identifier, do they associate it with a particular source?

That means a company can have:

  • one legal LLC name;

  • a different trade name or DBA;

  • one or more trademarks;

  • several product or service brands; and

  • domain names and social-media accounts associated with those brands.

Those things sometimes overlap, but legally they are not interchangeable.

What Is an Arizona Trade Name or DBA?

Arizona business owners frequently use the terms DBA and trade name when talking about a business operating under a name different from its legal entity name.

For example:

Desert Ventures LLC might operate a retail business under the name Sonoran Supply Co.

The LLC remains Desert Ventures LLC, but consumers may know the business only as Sonoran Supply Co.

Arizona trade names are registered through the Arizona Secretary of State rather than the Arizona Corporation Commission. The Secretary of State describes a trade name as similar to a “doing business as” or DBA name and specifically states that registering a trade name does not grant exclusive rights to the business name.

That last part is critical.

A trade-name filing may permit you to document that your business operates under a particular name. It does notamount to a legal determination that you are entitled to use that name without infringing someone else's trademark.

Can You Keep Your Existing LLC and Simply Adopt a New Trade Name?

Potentially, yes.

If a business decides to rebrand following a trademark dispute, it may sometimes be possible to retain the underlying LLC and conduct future business under a completely different trade name.

This can be considerably easier than forming an entirely new entity or changing the LLC's legal name.

But whether that strategy is appropriate depends heavily on what the business has actually agreed to do.

For example, there is an important difference between agreeing:

“We will cease using OLD BRAND as a trademark or trade name in commerce.”

and agreeing:

“We will legally change the name of Old Brand LLC.”

If a settlement agreement or negotiated resolution expressly requires an amendment to the LLC's legal name, registering a DBA may not satisfy that contractual obligation.

On the other hand, if the real concern is stopping the challenged name from being presented to consumers as the source of the company's products or services, operating under a new, properly cleared trade name may sometimes accomplish that objective without changing the underlying entity.

The wording matters.

This is one reason businesses negotiating trademark disputes should think not only about whether they are willing to rebrand, but exactly what the transition requires.

The Biggest Mistake: Picking the Replacement Name Too Quickly

Once a business decides to abandon a brand, there is an understandable urge to move quickly.

You need a new website.

New social media handles.

New product labels.

New packaging.

New email addresses.

Customers need to know what is happening.

The sales team needs something to tell accounts.

So the owners brainstorm a replacement name, search Google, check whether the domain is available, search the Arizona business database, and—if everything looks good—start over.

That can be a very expensive mistake.

Before investing in the replacement brand, conduct trademark clearance.

The USPTO specifically recommends conducting a comprehensive clearance search before filing a trademark application. That search may include federal applications and registrations, state trademark databases, and internet sources that can reveal businesses with potentially relevant unregistered rights.

A search is not limited to asking:

“Is this exact name federally registered?”

That is only the beginning.

Trademark Conflicts Do Not Require Identical Names

Suppose your proposed mark is:

SONORA BRIDAL

You search the USPTO database and find no exact registration for SONORA BRIDAL.

That does not necessarily mean the name is clear.

Trademark law generally focuses on likelihood of confusion. The USPTO explains that trademarks can be confusingly similar based on appearance, sound, meaning, or overall commercial impression. The goods and services also do not have to be identical; they only need to be sufficiently related that consumers could mistakenly believe they come from the same source.

So a clearance search may need to investigate names such as:

SONORAN BRIDE

SONORA

CASA SONORA

SONORA COUTURE

or other variations, depending upon what they identify and how the marks are used.

A competent search also considers the relationship between the goods and services.

For example, bridal gowns, formalwear, bridal accessories, online clothing retail services, and related fashion goods may present different levels of trademark risk depending on the marks involved and the marketplace.

This is why typing your proposed name into the USPTO search box and finding “no results” is not the same thing as receiving a legal clearance opinion.

An Available Arizona Business Name Does Not Mean an Available Trademark

This distinction deserves emphasis.

The Arizona Corporation Commission applies a distinguishability standard to entity names. That administrative standard can permit differences that would not necessarily eliminate a trademark problem.

The ACC specifically states that its approval of an entity name does not grant rights in the name and does not prevent another party from asserting superior trademark or common-law rights.

Likewise, the Arizona Secretary of State states that registering a trade name does not grant exclusive rights to that name.

So all of the following can theoretically be true at the same time:

The Arizona trade name is available.

The LLC name is available.

The domain name is available.

The Instagram handle is available.

And the name still presents a trademark problem.

That surprises many entrepreneurs.

Government databases are performing different functions. None should be treated as a substitute for trademark clearance.

Your Domain Name Does Not Give You Trademark Rights Either

Another common misconception involves domain names.

A business may have owned a valuable .com address for years and understandably believe that ownership provides some legal right to the corresponding name.

But domain registration and trademark rights are different.

The USPTO explains that merely registering a domain name does not provide trademark rights. A domain name may function as a trademark when it is actually used in a source-identifying manner, but registration with a domain registrar alone does not establish trademark ownership.

That becomes especially important during a rebrand.

The old domain may still have value because customers know it, search engines have indexed it, and links around the internet point to it. A business transitioning away from a disputed brand may therefore want to negotiate issues involving:

  • continued temporary use of the old website;

  • redirects to the new website;

  • disclaimers;

  • deadlines for discontinuing use;

  • transfer or sale of the domain;

  • email addresses;

  • social-media accounts; and

  • handling communications intended for the other business.

Those details can be just as important commercially as the legal decision to change the name.

A Thoughtful Rebrand Needs a Transition Plan

Trademark disputes are not resolved merely by choosing a new logo.

If a business agrees to discontinue a mark, counsel should consider everywhere the old brand appears.

Depending on the business, that could include:

  • sewn-in garment labels;

  • product packaging;

  • invoices;

  • catalogs;

  • business cards;

  • signage;

  • advertisements;

  • wholesale materials;

  • websites;

  • email signatures;

  • social-media profiles;

  • marketplace accounts;

  • domain names; and

  • promotional materials.

There may also be existing inventory bearing the old name.

A negotiated resolution can sometimes provide a reasonable sell-off or transition period rather than requiring everything to disappear overnight. The appropriate solution depends on the circumstances and the respective legal positions of the parties.

This is why a trademark dispute should be approached as both a legal problem and a business transition problem.

Rebranding Can Also Be an Opportunity

No business owner wants to spend money changing a name because of a trademark dispute.

But if rebranding is ultimately the right strategic decision, it creates an opportunity to build a stronger trademark portfolio the second time around.

Before committing to the replacement brand:

Choose a distinctive name.

Names that are arbitrary, fanciful, or otherwise distinctive are generally easier to protect than names that primarily describe the goods or services.

Conduct a comprehensive trademark clearance search.

Look beyond exact matches and beyond the federal database.

Investigate common-law use.

Federal registrations are not the only source of trademark rights. The USPTO notes that trademark rights can arise through use even without federal registration, although those rights may initially be geographically limited.

Secure the digital assets.

Check domains and relevant social-media handles as part of the branding process—but remember that their availability does not establish trademark clearance.

Consider federal registration early.

Once the business has selected a strong, cleared mark, federal registration may provide significant advantages and broader protection.

Most importantly, do the legal work before spending thousands of dollars on packaging, signs, advertising, inventory, web development, and brand promotion.

Received a Trademark Letter—or Planning a New Brand in Arizona?

If you have received a cease-and-desist letter, discovered another business using a similar name, or are preparing to launch a new brand, the first step should be understanding the actual trademark risk.

At Tucson Trademarks, we help Arizona entrepreneurs and small businesses evaluate trademark conflicts, conduct comprehensive trademark searches and clearance, develop registration strategies, and protect brands before substantial money is invested in them.

Sometimes the best strategy is defending the existing brand.

Sometimes it is negotiating coexistence or a transition.

And sometimes rebranding is the most economical business decision.

Whatever the answer, the goal should be to make that decision before the next investment in branding—not after another trademark dispute arises.

If you are starting a business, changing a business name, or selecting a replacement brand after a trademark conflict, contact Tucson Trademarks to discuss a comprehensive trademark search and clearance strategy.

This article provides general information about trademark and Arizona business-name issues and is not legal advice for any particular business or dispute.

Previous
Previous

Can You Hire Your Kids in Your Arizona Business?

Next
Next

Trademark Confusion Is About More Than Buying From the Wrong Business